Morelos, Coahuila De Zaragoza
1.1K views 13 comments

Ok so I originally bought a Magic Jack, despite its limitation of having to be plugged into a computer that is on in order to work. Now they have come out with the Magic Jack Plus and it works with or without a computer so I want to upgrade.

I check to see if they have an upgrade program and am told no that I have to pay FULL PRICE and can't even transfer my existing years of service that I have left over. I tell them how unfair this is for loyal existing customers that have bought the original Magic Jack in good faith believing this was one of the most and best cost effective way to make calls even though it couldn't be used without a computer. I also tell them that to advertise a product as that best most cost effective method and then develop a new product that can call without computers and expect customers who bought the other product in good faith to pay FULL PRICE to upgrade is just A SCAM!!!

Magic Jack is A SCAM!!! DO NOT buy ANY Magic Jack products EVER!!!

Review about: Magicjack Plus.

Review #275303 is a subjective opinion of a user.

Reason of Review / Monetary Loss Not specified / Not specified
Preferred solution Not specified

Had an Experience with Magicjack?

Write a review


Comment as anonymous or
Terms of Service
Post Comment

Basic Talk also has issues, but at 9.99 dollars per month I have nothing to complain about.On customer rep said I had two accounts, which I must have done.

Yet he would not give the account number. Finally after a couple months a rep gave me the info. They had sent out two units.

I did not have to return the second unit.Website is worthless.


As an active duty Army soldier stationed at Fort Hood, TX my wife and I purchased MagicJack Plus to lower our cell phone bill. Being stationed 2100 miles from our family we like to make regular calls home, and with a newborn baby we call for advice and to hear a friendly voice when the distance becomes to much to bear.After using MagicJack Plus for approximately 7 months, my account was unable to make calls. I contacted the company via "Live Help" and was informed my account was terminated due to violating the Terms of Service. After researching this issue its abundantly clear consumer fraud is happening at an alarming rate. I would like to see enough people dealing with this issue to become involved that a class action law suit could be initiated to stop this fraudulent company from stealing the money of hard working Americans.

Sign my petition at Change dot org

Magic Jack, LP: Release Call Logs of Terminated Accounts

to Brent #1009153

For 22 dollars, full documentation and possible recordings you will have fun in court especially if you get Judge Judy!


I am a bit skeptical about this company.The Magic Jack Plus sounds great, and is getting great press, but their infomercial is MISLEADING and WRONG.

The guy say and it's written over the screen that it is $19.95 per year for Magic Jack PLUS. When I went to the website it said that it is $29.95 per year. That is blatant false advertising. I went ahead anyway because it seems like a good deal.

I'm currently using Vonage at that price per month.

BUT I'm a little skeptical, especially after reading some of the problems people have been having.Just FYI.

Mount Vernon, Maine, United States #380238

@ Michael please re-evaluate your argument.

You’re comparing a component (PEN) with a service (5 years telephone service).

If I buy a pen (component) from Office Max which is later upgraded by an improved one, then of course NO one would ask for credit towards the new pen.

However, if you have a magic jack and you upgrade to the magic jack plus (purchased the new hardware). Why shouldn’t a customer be able to transfer 4 years of the service over to the magic jack plus and pay the difference?

Magic Jack yearly service $19.99

Magic Jack Plus yearly service $29.99

It’s only logical that the author “Anonymous” of this magic jack plus complaint has a point. Scam maybe not, unethical definitely!


How can you advertise UNLIMITED calling in the U.S.and Canada, and then put a qualifier on that in your Terms of Service Agreement?

In that you say that if a person calls 20 percent more than your other 10 million users average that person's service will be terminated with no refund. Come on MJ...really???

What does UNLIMITED mean to you?It's thru the internet provider doesn't say I can't be on 24x7 if I wish.



Are you kidding me, this thing is dirt, yes dirt cheap. Im guessing you cant please 100% of the people 100% of the time even if the product is almost FREE!

Im sure you would be complaining if the product was free too!

Do you complain to office Max when your favorite pen company comes out with a brand new pen 10 times better that your old one. No idot you go out and buy your new pen and enjoy the added features of it.

Do you say to the Samsung well I want a discount on the new TV because I bought your brand TV last time? NO! Well maybe you do LOL

Also screwed by MJ

Yeah, I bought an original MJ and had nothing but trouble with it.When it came time to renew I wanted to just re-up for another year but there was no annual option, just a multi-year option.

Since I was about to upgrade my DSL I thought that might help the MJ so i went ahead with the multi-year MJ subscription. Faster DSL didn't help a bit.

So now the dickheads won't even carry over the pre-paid subscription to a new device they claim will fix the problems of the old device.I wouldn't mind paying for the new hardware.

Gerry C.
Wavell Heights, Queensland, Australia #377180

I recently purchased a MagicJack Plus.It installed fine and worked great, except I found out a couple days later my in-laws could not call me.

They only live 5 miles away. AFter a week of trying to resolve this, I decided to port my number back to a landline phone. Magic Jack had already charged me $20 to port to them, and then they charged me $30 to port back. My phone company never charged me anything.

I think I will continue pursuing this.It is a shame they have for the most part a unique product, but their lousy customer service, and constant charging for this type of stuff is somewhat unbearable


Most reputable "service" companies offer existing customers some small discount to UPGRADE to a newer version and ALL REPUTABLE companies allow you to TRANSFER PREPAID SERVICE to a new version ... all except Magic Jack!

You May Also Like

Icsolutions - Ic solutions, shady fraudulent company Icsolutions "They failed to provide the fact that it is strictly a middle man company, and that after purchasing your local number you still have to pay for an account directly..." Read more Rise Broadband - TERRRIBBBLLLEEE! Rise Broadband "They charged me for 15Mb for over a year with poor bandwidth all the way. FINALLY a tech came out and said the tower won't even do over 5Mb. What..." Read more Centurylink - Poorest Customer "Service", Most Unreliable Internet Speeds Centurylink "Ever since I moved to a rural area, I have been experiencing daily disruptions of internet service. Come to find out, the entire community is having the same problem. Generally,..." Read more Buy Squad - Not a new TV + shipping insurance after order Buy Squad "PLEASE DO YOURSELF A FAVOR----> DO NOT BUY anything from Buy Squad. Honestly, after researching on this company, I feel so *** to fall for their "low price" ;0( I ordered..." Read more Dennys Restaurant - Most racist and dissapoint​ing experience ever Dennys Restaurant "Waiter was racist. Refused to serve us because my fiance is African American. Once server ended up serving us he did not EVER give my fiance her food and then..." Read more Threads King - THREADSKING IS A SCAM Threads King "Items constantly "lost in transit" Rude replies from customer service Does NOT give refund as they claim they would AWFUL DO NOT BUY FROM THEM You WILL loose your money!..." Read more Lending Club - Slow confusing process with absolutely no communication Lending Club "I am currently around two weeks since our application. We decided to give Lending Club a try, pre-qualified for a loan, submitted all requested documentation immediately upon request. After a..." Read more Cooking Club Of America - Where did it go? Cooking Club Of America "I loved my monthly magazine and the products I purchased from them and when you pay for a lifetime membership, you expect to continue getting what you paid in advance...." Read more